Thursday, January 5, 2012

Newt Gingrich's "timid" anti-Romney ad



The Washington Post reports:

The former House speaker launched a TV ad Thursday in New Hampshire and South Carolina, the first in which he challenges Romney.

“Romney’s economic plan? Timid,” the spot says. “Parts of it virtually identical to Obama’s failed policy. Timid won’t create jobs and timid certainly won’t defeat Barack Obama.

The ad highlights Gingrich’s “bold leadership” and says: “The Gingrich jobs plan: A powerful plan for growing our economy and creating new jobs.”
The ad uses the word "timid" three times. Even when you'd expect to see the noun form — "timidity" — the ad still uses the adjective "timid" as if it were a noun. So, Gingrich clearly decided that "timid" is a word that could stick to Mitt Romney.

It seems like the creators of the ad decided to play around with the name "Mitt," so they flipped it over to get "tiM," flopped it back so it's "Mitt" again, then put them side by side to get "tiM-Mitt," which sounds like "timid."

Aside from whatever substance their might be to Gingrich's disagreements with Romney's economic policy, the undertone to this ad is that we're supposed to view Romney as too cautious, too restrained, too afraid to do the kinds of huge things Gingrich likes to do. Whether that will convince voters that Romney is the less conservative candidate, I'm not sure.

Personally (though I can't claim to be representative of voters in the Republican primaries), I like the idea of a candidate who's cautious and sensible, not prone to making rash decisions. I might even care about this more than any conventional distinction of left vs. right.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

"Timid" is the word The Wall Street Journal used.

It's also how CNN Money described Romney's tax plan.

Gingrich is over in the general primarily because of the video of him with Frank Luntz-even though Frank thinks he helped him.

Anonymous said...

People probably want a correction from Obama-who was not timid-although he sold himself as this:

I like the idea of a candidate who's cautious and sensible, not prone to making rash decisions.

GIven a "choice" between Romney or Obama-if Romney isn't much different....

rhhardin said...

It's not a noun. It's an ellipsis, the missing word being "Being."

It's put that way for focus.

John Althouse Cohen said...

"Timid" is the word The Wall Street Journal used.

Gingrich chose to use the word three times in his ad. The Wall Street Journal didn't make him do that. A political ad uses newspaper quotes like scraps in a collage.

Jason (the commenter) said...

Personally (though I can't claim to be representative of voters in the Republican primaries), I like the idea of a candidate who's cautious and sensible, not prone to making rash decisions.

In other words, boring. I think it would work wonders if Romney ran as the "boring" candidate. It's when he tries to seem interesting that makes him look fake and disingenuous.

John Althouse Cohen said...

Conversely, should excitement be our top priority in choosing a president? I don't think so.