skip to main | skip to sidebar

Jaltcoh

"He has a sensitivity to the limits of men knowing Truth
together with a courage to push those limits in many areas." -- a reader

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Constructive criticism

It's not the only kind of criticism worth giving.


Posted by John Althouse Cohen on Tuesday, November 13, 2012
Tags: church of rationality, rationality

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)


New to this blog?

You might want to start with my all-time favorite posts.

Or see what people have said.

Or read my favorite quotes that I've blogged.

This blog doesn't have one specific focus, but there are many themes. To filter the blog by topic, click on one of the tags at the end of each post (or in the list near the end of this column).

Search my blog (or other sites)

Loading...

Subscribe to Feeds

Posts
Atom
Posts
Comments
Atom
Comments

Archive

  • ►  2013 (31)
    • ►  June 2013 (5)
    • ►  May 2013 (4)
    • ►  April 2013 (6)
    • ►  March 2013 (5)
    • ►  February 2013 (10)
    • ►  January 2013 (1)
  • ▼  2012 (170)
    • ►  December 2012 (14)
    • ▼  November 2012 (15)
      • Warren Buffett's weird editorial on capital gains ...
      • A theory of the Obama presidency
      • Twinkies
      • How to expand the government
      • A slight problem with the "new poverty measure"
      • Judge Richard Posner's bad reason to keep the elec...
      • Constructive criticism
      • Can Jon Huntsman save the Republican Party?
      • "Obama win may be good news for Pakistan flag-make...
      • How can Republicans win after 2012?
      • Why are people so much smarter at making personal ...
      • Live-blogging the final presidential debate of 201...
      • Why it matters that drones haven't been debated in...
      • Why politicians lie
      • Businesses help people
    • ►  October 2012 (15)
    • ►  September 2012 (13)
    • ►  August 2012 (17)
    • ►  July 2012 (4)
    • ►  June 2012 (15)
    • ►  May 2012 (15)
    • ►  April 2012 (7)
    • ►  March 2012 (8)
    • ►  February 2012 (14)
    • ►  January 2012 (33)
  • ►  2011 (260)
    • ►  December 2011 (28)
    • ►  November 2011 (26)
    • ►  October 2011 (28)
    • ►  September 2011 (35)
    • ►  August 2011 (25)
    • ►  July 2011 (11)
    • ►  June 2011 (15)
    • ►  May 2011 (15)
    • ►  April 2011 (20)
    • ►  March 2011 (21)
    • ►  February 2011 (17)
    • ►  January 2011 (19)
  • ►  2010 (229)
    • ►  December 2010 (15)
    • ►  November 2010 (19)
    • ►  October 2010 (33)
    • ►  September 2010 (29)
    • ►  August 2010 (23)
    • ►  July 2010 (6)
    • ►  June 2010 (23)
    • ►  May 2010 (15)
    • ►  April 2010 (22)
    • ►  March 2010 (16)
    • ►  February 2010 (11)
    • ►  January 2010 (17)
  • ►  2009 (302)
    • ►  December 2009 (14)
    • ►  November 2009 (17)
    • ►  October 2009 (23)
    • ►  September 2009 (18)
    • ►  August 2009 (17)
    • ►  July 2009 (19)
    • ►  June 2009 (27)
    • ►  May 2009 (39)
    • ►  April 2009 (40)
    • ►  March 2009 (36)
    • ►  February 2009 (23)
    • ►  January 2009 (29)
  • ►  2008 (161)
    • ►  December 2008 (20)
    • ►  November 2008 (20)
    • ►  October 2008 (19)
    • ►  September 2008 (20)
    • ►  August 2008 (22)
    • ►  July 2008 (18)
    • ►  June 2008 (19)
    • ►  May 2008 (15)
    • ►  April 2008 (8)

Links to this blog

Loading...
(more)

This blog is by ...

P1050537
John Althouse Cohen
New York, NY

You can find me on ...

  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • LinkedIn

My email address is johncohen+delete @ gmail.com. (Please delete the word "delete"; otherwise, your message will go to my spam folder.)

Great Blogs

  • Achenblog
    Asteroid redirect mission: impossible?
  • Althouse
    Goodbye to James Gandolfini.
  • Asymmetrical Information - Megan McArdle
    Building a Better Clinical Trial System
  • Bad Science
    Discussing AllTrials on the BBC Daily Politics today
  • Barking up the wrong tree
    6 hostage negotiation techniques that will get you what you want
  • Becker-Posner Blog
    Reform of the Tax Code-Becker
  • Boing Boing
    Tell Me Something I Don't Know 009: John Porcellino
  • BPS Research Digest
    Simple fist-squeezing procedure helps athletes avoid choking under pressure
  • Brazen Careerist - Penelope Trunk
    For God’s sake, do the first thing on your to do list first
  • Conversable Economist - Timothy Taylor
    Global Energy Snapshots
  • Dr. Helen
  • EconLog
    Uncertainty Can Go Both Ways, by David Henderson
  • Instapundit
    WHILE PEOPLE WORRY ABOUT TECHNOLOGY KILLING JOBS, REGULATION IS THE BIG KILLER: Department of Labor…
  • Julian Sanchez
    Nadler and Mueller on Analysts Getting Call and E-mail Content
  • KausFiles
    Let’s Make Some Campaign Ads!
  • kottke.org - AideRSS (Best)
    The Homeric social network
  • Marginal Revolution - Tyler Cowen
    The passing of James Gandolfini
  • Meteuphoric
    Failure in the marketplace of ideas
  • Obsidian Wings
    yay!
  • Overcoming Bias
    Whistleblowers Think Far
  • Psychology Today blogs
    How Technology is Changing the Way Children Think and Focus
  • The Church of Rationality
    Estimating the Effect of Helmet Laws on Cycling-related Injuries: You Can't Do It Like That
  • Volokh Conspiracy
    Sens. Tester & Murphy’s Constitutional Amendment Would Strip Rights from Corporate-Owned Newspapers, Advocacy Groups, Etc.

Family and Friends of Jaltcoh

  • Althouse
  • Church of Rationality
  • Crazier than Shirttails - Summer Anne
  • Karl Cronin
  • Freeman Hunt
  • Grobstein
  • Incorrigible Dicta
  • Alex Knepper
  • Living in a Golden Age
  • Lonnie Bannon
  • Lost in the Funhouse
  • Maenad
  • The Me Blog
  • Measure of Doubt
  • New America Tour
  • Random Thoughts of the Utmost Importance
  • Rationally Speaking
  • RLC
  • Sire Says
  • Smarter
  • Stubborn Facts
  • Stuff Running 'Round My Head
  • Sweety Meadey Potato
  • The Time That Blog Forgot
  • Unstable Arc: From Cambridge to Conflict
  • Robert Wiblin on Overcoming Bias
  • Ben Wikler

Filters

  • 3quarksdaily
    Walt Whitman's American Philosophy
  • Arts & Letters Daily
    Hazard’s “The Crisis of the European Mind”
  • Atlantic Politics Channel
    Dems Hijack GOP's Frederick Douglass Party to Stump for D.C. Statehood
  • BBC News
    Corbisiero named in Lions Test side
  • Daily Beast - Cheat Sheet
    Naval Academy Charges 3 in Assault
  • Memeorandum
    Irish parliamentarians spar over 'war criminal' Obama's summit visit (Julian Pecquet/The Hill)
  • MetaFilter
    Subjective Cartography
  • Slatest
    Why iPhone Users Should Care About Tracking

More Blogs

  • Agorophilia
  • The American Scene
  • Balkinization
  • Brainiac
  • Capital Gains & Games - Bruce Bartlett
  • Ben Casnocha
  • Caterina
  • Cato @ Liberty
  • Jonathan Chait
  • Creature Talk
  • Crooked Timber
  • Dvorak Uncensored
  • Dyske
  • EconLog
  • Economist - Daily Chart
  • Economist - Democracy in America
  • Eschaton (Atrios)
  • Fourth Checkraise
  • Freakonomics
  • Tim Harford
  • In Over Your Head
  • IWF - Inkwell
  • Language Log
  • The Frontal Cortex - Jonah Lehrer
  • Letters of Note
  • Liberal War Journal
  • Lileks
  • London Review of Books Blog
  • Lowering the Bar
  • Mentaculus - Andy McKenzie
  • MetaChat
  • Mind Hacks
  • Neo-Neocon
  • Nudge - Sunstein & Thaler
  • Obscure Store & Reading Room
  • A Plain Blog About Politics
  • Practical Environmentalist
  • Protein Wisdom
  • PsyBlog
  • Psychothalamus
  • Research Blogging
  • Simple Dollar
  • Style & Substance
  • Andrew Sullivan
  • David Thompson
  • Blogslot - Bill Walsh
  • Washington Independent Blog
  • Weird Things
  • Robert Wright
  • Matthew Yglesias - Moneybox
  • Zen Habits

Columnists

  • William Saletan
    Scandal 2.0
  • David Brooks
    Border Raids
  • Thomas Sowell
    The Loss of Trust
  • Jonah Goldberg
    The Explosion
  • Nicholas Kristof
    Exploiting the Prophet
  • Peter Beinart
  • John McWhorter

Philosophy

  • Animal Ethics
  • Ask Philosophers
  • BBC - In Our Time (podcasts)
  • Experimental Philosophy
  • Flickers of Freedom
  • Garden of Forking Paths
  • Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  • Less Wrong
  • Mark Vernon's Philosophy and Life Blog
  • Neurophilosophy
  • Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews
  • Pea Soup
  • Philosophers' Imprint
  • Philosophical blogs
  • Philosophy Bites (podcasts)
  • Philosophy TV
  • Philosophy, etc.
  • PhilPapers
  • Splintered Mind
  • Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  • The Pinocchio Theory
  • Think Tonk

Video

  • Bloggingheads.tv
  • C-SPAN
  • Gawker.tv
  • TED
  • TPMtv

Images

  • 50 underwater photos
  • Animaestro
  • Artchive
  • Bldg Blog
  • Daily Dose of Imagery
  • Drawn!
  • Flickr Blog
  • Flickr Interestingness
  • FormFiftyFive
  • Information Is Beautiful
  • Infosthetics
  • Manhattan Street Project
  • Picdit
  • Sociological Images
  • Strange Maps

Music

  • All Classical FM
  • Amazon mp3 Deals
  • AOL Sessions
  • Beethoven's piano sonatas (Andras Schiff)
  • CBC Radio
  • ClassicsToday (reviews)
  • Daytrotter
  • di.fm
  • Discogs
  • JazzWax
  • KEXP 90.3 FM
  • NPR Music
  • Piano Society
  • Pitchfork - Forkcast
  • SomaFM
  • Stereogum
  • Symphony Salon
  • The Classical Station.org
  • The Distance
  • The Rest Is Noise

Mirth

  • Bizarro Blog
  • Cartoons Drawn on the Back of Business Cards
  • Dark Roasted Blend
  • Hyperbole and a Half
  • McSweeney's Lists
  • Overheard in New York
  • Paleofuture
  • Passive Aggressive Notes
  • Presurfer
  • Tiny Art Director
  • Websites Then and Now
  • XKCD

Defunct but Worthy

  • Cognitive Daily
  • Kausfiles on Slate
  • Megan McArdle on The Atlantic
  • NYT - Idea of the Day
  • This is Broken
  • Will Wilkinson

Nonblogs

  • The American
  • Big Questions Online
  • Breakthrough Journal
  • Butterflies and Wheels
  • City Journal
  • Columbia Journalism Review
  • Discover - Animal Intelligence
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Miller-McCune
  • NYT Letters
  • Powell's Author Interviews
  • ProPublica
  • Scientific American
  • Slate
  • The New Republic
  • John Allen Paulos - Who's Counting?
  • Wilson Quarterly
  • World Question Center - Edge

Useful Resources

  • 43 Folders
  • 43 Places
  • AskMetafilter
  • Bartleby
  • BookForum
  • ChangeThis
  • Eye on the Stimulus - ProPublica
  • First chapters on NYT
  • First chapters on WaPo
  • FiveThirtyEight
  • FreeRice
  • Get Rich Slowly
  • Google Blog Search
  • LifeHack
  • NameVoyager
  • Opposing Views
  • Pollster
  • Project Gutenberg Top 100
  • Straight Dope
  • Swivel Graphs
  • U.S. Constitution Annotated
  • WikiHow
  • Wikipedia - current events
  • Wikisource - random page
  • Wordie

New York City

  • Gothamist
  • NewYorkology
  • NYT - City Room
  • Scouting NY
  • TimeOut New York

Tags (selected)

  • 2008 campaign moments (5)
  • abortion (12)
  • advertisements (10)
  • africa (9)
  • afterlife (7)
  • alcohol (5)
  • althouse (75)
  • animals (34)
  • anti-vegetarian argument (2)
  • appearance (11)
  • arcade fire (6)
  • beatles (9)
  • biden (8)
  • bill clinton (8)
  • bittman (4)
  • blogger of the day (5)
  • blogging (21)
  • blogging a book (25)
  • bloggingheads (45)
  • books (22)
  • boredom (5)
  • brain (14)
  • bush (14)
  • camera obscura (6)
  • cancer (4)
  • careers (24)
  • cars (17)
  • cartoons (8)
  • celebrity (6)
  • church of rationality (9)
  • clarity (6)
  • classical (19)
  • coffee (4)
  • computers (7)
  • concert (2)
  • Congress (5)
  • conquest of happiness (6)
  • conservatives (15)
  • consumerism (14)
  • cool blog concept (6)
  • crime (35)
  • cultural degradation (10)
  • DADT (4)
  • dating (9)
  • death (38)
  • death penalty (12)
  • debate (35)
  • Democrats (6)
  • descartes (2)
  • discourse (7)
  • doubt (24)
  • drinking age (2)
  • drugs (13)
  • economic crisis (28)
  • economics (81)
  • education (26)
  • emotions (9)
  • empirical studies (7)
  • environment (29)
  • epistemology (16)
  • ethics (32)
  • Europe (13)
  • evil (26)
  • evolutionary psychology (13)
  • experts (21)
  • facebook (12)
  • family (32)
  • fiscal responsibility (16)
  • food (33)
  • foreign policy (12)
  • fort wilson riot (4)
  • free speech (13)
  • free will (9)
  • gender (75)
  • gore (3)
  • greatest songs of the 2000s (15)
  • green day (3)
  • grunge (14)
  • guitar (3)
  • happiness (11)
  • haydn (2)
  • health (32)
  • health care (32)
  • helping people (10)
  • hillary clinton (16)
  • hitchens (10)
  • holiday (21)
  • homeless (3)
  • hume (3)
  • humor (8)
  • identity (9)
  • ideological feuds (2)
  • imogen heap (5)
  • intellectual adventurousness (8)
  • intelligence (9)
  • internet (33)
  • introvert/extrovert (7)
  • inventions (4)
  • jason (the commenter) (5)
  • jazz (10)
  • Jonah Goldberg (12)
  • kant (2)
  • kaus (31)
  • language (40)
  • law (33)
  • law school (4)
  • liberals (33)
  • life (33)
  • literature (13)
  • live-blog (24)
  • loury (14)
  • love (10)
  • marriage (15)
  • McSweeney's (3)
  • mcwhorter (24)
  • meat (7)
  • mental health (7)
  • metablog (47)
  • metafilter (26)
  • michael jackson (8)
  • middle east (17)
  • mind-body problem (4)
  • mistakes (19)
  • money (18)
  • movies (16)
  • mozart (2)
  • music (121)
  • music in life (27)
  • nagel (5)
  • nirvana (7)
  • nyc (23)
  • nyt (76)
  • NYT's gender bias (4)
  • Obama '08 (31)
  • obit (32)
  • observed morality (6)
  • old vs. new media (8)
  • past (8)
  • philosophy (35)
  • politics (29)
  • poll (14)
  • posner (10)
  • President Obama (95)
  • presidents (8)
  • problem of the absurd (2)
  • psychology (40)
  • public decency (2)
  • punishment (2)
  • quality of life (2)
  • race (47)
  • raising children (15)
  • real-life conversations (20)
  • religion (57)
  • republicans (27)
  • revealed preferences (6)
  • rhetoric (6)
  • rich and poor (19)
  • rlc (21)
  • robert wright (19)
  • same-sex marriage (17)
  • science (27)
  • scientists (4)
  • searches that have referred people to this blog (4)
  • searle (3)
  • sex (23)
  • sexual orientation (27)
  • sowell (17)
  • statistics (21)
  • stimulus (10)
  • studies show (12)
  • terrorism (36)
  • tnr (61)
  • torture (12)
  • transport (10)
  • twitter (15)
  • unintended consequences (23)
  • united states (18)
  • unknown people (7)
  • vegetarian (9)
  • victims (3)
  • violence (10)
  • voting (7)
  • war (31)
  • world (27)
  • writing (8)
  • XKCD (3)
  • yglesias (26)
  • zeldin (2)
The photo at the top of this blog is "Burned Poster Remains", from Stewart Butterfield's great set of Roman textures.

StatCounter

Unique visitors to this blog:

View complete stats

Creative Commons

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.